WE SEE SAME DAY EMERGENCIES! Contact us after hours!


Contact us after hours!

2nd Molar Extraction vs Root Canal

2nd Molar Extraction vs Root Canal: Which Is The Better Option In 2024?

Are you faced with the dilemma of choosing between a second molar extraction or a root canal? This decision can be difficult and full of uncertainty. 

Extracting a molar means losing a tooth, which can affect chewing and alignment, while root canals are often associated with pain and multiple visits. 

We will focus on the pros and cons of both procedures, shedding light on possible complications and long-term effects. 

By the end of this article, you will have an overall understanding of which option might be better for your dental health, helping you make an informed and confident decision.

2nd Molar Extraction vs Root Canal

What is a Root Canal Treatment?

Root canal treatment is a dental procedure designed to treat infection at the center of a tooth. This treatment involves the removal of infected or damaged pulp.

  • Procedure Overview: The process typically involves three key steps:
  • Removing the infected pulp, cleaning and shaping the root canals, and filling and sealing the tooth.
  • Purpose: The main goal of root canal treatment is to save a tooth that would otherwise need to be extracted, preserving its function and appearance.

Symptoms of Root Canal Treatment

Understanding when a root canal is necessary involves recognizing specific symptoms that indicate pulp infection or damage:

Persistent PainContinuous or severe tooth pain, especially when chewing or applying pressure.
SensitivityProlonged sensitivity to hot or cold temperatures, even after the source is removed.
Swelling and TendernessSwelling and tenderness in nearby gums, possibly including a small bump or pimple-like sore.
DiscolorationDarkening of the tooth, indicating internal damage or decay.
Drainage and AbscessPresence of pus or an abscess, leading to bad breath or a foul taste in the mouth.

These symptoms suggest that the pulp inside the tooth is infected or inflamed, necessitating root canal therapy to alleviate pain and save the tooth.

Recommended Reading: Symptoms of Jaw Infection After Root Canal

What is 2nd Molar Extraction?

2nd molar extraction is a dental procedure to remove the second molar, typically due to severe decay, infection, or trauma. The process involves numbing the area, loosening the tooth, and carefully extracting it. 

According to the American Dental Association, extractions are often necessary when teeth are beyond repair to prevent further oral health issues.

  • Procedure Overview: The extraction process involves numbing the area with a local anesthetic, loosening the tooth from its socket, and then carefully removing it. In some cases, surgical extraction may be needed if the tooth is impacted or broken.

  • Purpose: The primary goal of 2nd molar extraction is to remove a tooth that cannot be saved, thereby preventing further oral health issues and alleviating pain.

Extraction of the second molar can help maintain overall oral health by eliminating sources of infection or damage that could affect surrounding teeth and tissues.

Recommended Reading: Root Canal vs Extraction Pros and Cons


2nd Molar Extraction Symptoms

Recognizing when a 2nd molar extraction is necessary involves identifying specific symptoms that indicate severe dental issues:

Severe ToothachePersistent, intense pain that doesn’t subside with over-the-counter pain medications.
Swelling and RednessSwelling, redness, and tenderness in the gums around the second molar, indicating infection.
Loose ToothA loose second molar due to advanced gum disease or significant bone loss around the tooth.
Extensive DecayVisible decay or damage that extends deep into the tooth, making it impossible to restore.
Recurrent InfectionsChronic or recurrent infections in the tooth, often with drainage of pus and bad breath.

Difference between 2nd Molar Extraction and Root Canal

A root canal involves removing infected pulp, cleaning, and sealing the tooth, with a success rate of 85-97% In contrast, 2nd molar extraction removes the tooth entirely, often leading to more significant pain, a longer recovery, and potential complications.

AspectRoot Canal Treatment2nd Molar Extraction
ProcedureRemoval of infected pulp, cleaning, disinfecting, and sealing the toothComplete removal of the second molar from its socket
Pain and RecoveryMild discomfort, quick recovery with pain relief in a few daysSignificant discomfort, longer recovery, risk of complications like dry socket
Success RateHigh success rate (85-97%), long-lasting with proper careDefinitive solution, but requires replacement options like implants or bridges
CostHigher initial cost, cost-effective long-term by preserving the toothLower initial cost, potentially higher long-term cost with prosthetic replacements
Functional OutcomeMaintains proper dental function and aesthetics by preserving the natural toothCan impact chewing efficiency, may cause shifting of adjacent teeth affecting overall alignment
Long-term Oral HealthMaintains tooth integrity, prevents further complicationsPotential future complications, such as bone loss and need for prosthetic solutions

Recommended Reading: Root Canal Treatment vs Wisdom Tooth Extraction

Do I Need 2nd Molar Extraction or Root Canal Treatment?

Root canal treatment, with a high success rate of 85-97%, is ideal for preserving a tooth with confined pulp damage. In contrast, extraction is necessary for severely decayed or structurally compromised teeth, though it may lead to bone loss and require future dental prosthetics.

Here are some key points to help guide your decision:

Assessment of Tooth Condition: Evaluate the extent of damage and infection in the tooth.

  • Root Canal: Best for confined pulp damage and intact surrounding structures.
  • Extraction: Necessary for severely decayed or structurally compromised teeth.

Pain and Discomfort: Consider the level of pain and discomfort associated with each procedure.

  • Root Canal: Involves minimal pain and discomfort, with a quick recovery period.
  • Extraction: Can lead to significant pain and a longer recovery period, with a higher risk of post-extraction complications.

Long-term Oral Health: Think about the impact on your oral health in the future.

  • Root Canal: Preserves the natural tooth, maintaining jawbone integrity and preventing shifting of adjacent teeth.
  • Extraction: May result in bone loss and require future dental prosthetics to maintain proper dental function and aesthetics.

Average Cost of Root Canal Treatment in Orlando

The average cost of root canal treatment in Orlando ranges from $600 to $1,400 per tooth. This cost varies based on the tooth’s location and complexity of the procedure. 

Additional Costs:

  • Dental crowns: After a root canal, a crown is often needed to protect the tooth. The cost of a crown can range from $500 to $2,000 depending on the material and type of crown used.
  • Consultation and X-rays: Initial consultation and X-rays may add $50 to $200 to the total cost.

Recommended Reading: How long is Root Canal Procedure

Average Cost of 2nd Molar Extraction in Orlando

Typically, the cost ranges from $150 to $400 per tooth. However, if the extraction is more complex, such as requiring surgical intervention, the price can increase to between $300 and $600.

Factors Influencing Cost:

  • Position of the Tooth: The location and alignment of the 2nd molar can affect the difficulty and, consequently, the cost of the extraction.
  • Type of Extraction: Simple extractions are less expensive than surgical extractions, which involve more intricate procedures.
  • Sedation Requirements: If sedation or anesthesia is necessary, this can add to the overall cost.

Additional Costs:

  • Consultation and X-rays: Initial assessments and X-rays can add $50 to $200 to the total expense.
  • Post-Extraction Care: Medications, follow-up visits, and potential complications may incur additional costs.

Recommended Reading: Can a Periodontist Do a Root Canal

Key Takeaways: 2nd Molar Extraction vs Root Canal

When deciding between a 2nd molar extraction and a root canal, several key factors should be considered to determine the best course of action for your dental health. Here are the main takeaways:

Preservation vs. Removal:

  • Root Canal: Aims to save the natural tooth by removing infected pulp and sealing the tooth. This procedure helps maintain the integrity and function of your bite and jawbone.
  • Extraction: Involves removing the tooth entirely, which may lead to bone loss and shifting of adjacent teeth over time.

Cost Considerations:

  • Root Canal: Typically costs between $600 and $1,400 depending on the tooth’s location and complexity. Dental crowns, which often follow root canals, add an additional $500 to $2,000.
  • Extraction: Less expensive, ranging from $150 to $600 depending on whether it is a simple or surgical extraction. However, future restorative procedures can increase overall costs.

Long-Term Implications:

  • Root Canal: Preserving the natural tooth often results in better long-term oral health and stability. It avoids the complications associated with missing teeth.
  • Extraction: While initially less expensive, it can lead to issues such as bone resorption and the need for further dental work to replace the lost tooth.

At East Orange Endodontics, our expert team can provide comprehensive evaluations and personalized recommendations to ensure you receive the best possible care tailored to your needs. 


Conclusion: 2nd Molar Extraction vs Root Canal

Root canals are ideal for preserving natural teeth, maintaining jaw integrity, and preventing shifting of adjacent teeth, while extractions may be necessary for severely damaged teeth but can lead to future dental complications.

At East Orange Endodontics, we provide expert evaluations and personalized care to help you choose the best treatment. Our goal is to ensure high-quality, affordable dental solutions that meet your specific needs, whether it’s a root canal or an extraction.

If you’re in need of root canal in Orlando ,consider visiting East Orange Endodontics. We´ve +30 years of experience and +450 positive reviews. Contact Us! We’ll be in touch with you in less than 10 minutes.

FAQs: Root Canal vs 2nd Molar Extraction

Is it better to get a root canal or pull a tooth back molar?

A root canal is generally better for preserving the natural tooth and maintaining jaw structure. It has a high success rate of over 90% and prevents shifting of adjacent teeth. Extraction is considered when the tooth is too damaged to save but can lead to bone loss and require future restorative work.

What happens to teeth when the 2nd molar is extracted?

When the 2nd molar is extracted, adjacent teeth can shift, leading to misalignment. Bone loss in the jaw can occur over time, and the gap may need to be filled with an implant or bridge to maintain proper dental function and aesthetics.

Related Posts

Let's save your tooth

Contact Us

We will get in touch as soon as possible!

Experiencing Tooth Pain? Book your Root Canal in Orlando, FL

Over 100,000 Root Canals Performed

30+ Years of Award-Winning Expertise

Top-Rated Endodontist

Choose proven experience !