WE SEE SAME DAY EMERGENCIES! Contact us after hours!


Contact us after hours!

Apicoectomy vs Root Canal

Apicoectomy vs Root Canal: Which Is The Better Option In 2024?

When faced with dental problems such as persistent infections or failed root canals, patients often seek alternatives such as apicoectomy. But which procedure is the most appropriate? 

In this article, we will focus on the problem of deciding between apicoectomy and endodontics, exploring the differences, advantages and disadvantages of each. From the turmoil of uncertainty to the confusion surrounding treatment options, we will address the most common concerns patients may encounter. 

By the end of this article, you will be equipped with the knowledge to make an informed decision about your dental health, ensuring you choose the most appropriate treatment for your needs.

Apicoectomy vs Root canal

What is Apicoectomy?

Apicoectomy, also known as root-end resection, is an endodontic surgical procedure primarily performed to treat persistent infections or inflammation in the root tip of a tooth.

It involves the removal of the apex (tip) of the tooth’s root and the surrounding infected tissue. This procedure aims to eliminate the source of infection and preserve the tooth.

How Does Apicoectomy Work?

  • Incision: The procedure begins with making a small incision in the gum tissue near the affected tooth to access the underlying bone and root.
  • Root Tip Removal: The infected or damaged tip of the tooth’s root is carefully removed using specialized instruments, along with any surrounding infected tissue.
  • Root-End Preparation: After the root tip removal, the end of the root canal is cleaned, shaped, and sometimes retrofilled with a biocompatible material to seal the apex.
  • Closure: The gum tissue is repositioned and sutured back into place to promote proper healing.

How to Know if You Need an Apicoectomy?

  • Persistent Symptoms: If you experience persistent symptoms such as pain, swelling, or drainage from the gum around a previously treated tooth, it may indicate the need for further intervention.
  • Radiographic Findings: X-rays revealing persistent infection, cysts, or granulomas at the root tip despite previous root canal treatment may suggest the need for an apicoectomy.
  • Tooth Fracture: In cases where a tooth has a fracture near the apex that cannot be treated through conventional root canal therapy, an apicoectomy may be recommended as a last resort to save the tooth.

What is a Root Canal?

A root canal, also known as endodontic therapy, is a dental procedure aimed at saving a tooth that is severely damaged or infected, particularly in cases where the inner pulp becomes inflamed or infected. 

Here are some key points about root canals:

  • Pulp Removal: During a root canal, the infected or damaged pulp inside the tooth is carefully removed to eliminate infection and alleviate pain.
  • Cleaning and Sealing: After the pulp is removed, the inside of the tooth is thoroughly cleaned, disinfected, and then filled and sealed to prevent further infection.
  • Preservation of Tooth: Root canal treatment aims to preserve the natural tooth structure and function, avoiding the need for extraction and maintaining oral health and aesthetics.

How do Root Canals Work?

Root canals involve several steps to effectively treat and save a damaged or infected tooth. Here’s how the process typically works:

  • Assessment: The dentist examines the tooth and may take X-rays to assess the extent of damage or infection.
  • Anesthesia: Local anesthesia is administered to numb the affected tooth and surrounding area, ensuring the patient’s comfort during the procedure.
  • Access: The dentist creates an opening in the crown of the tooth to access the pulp chamber and root canals.
  • Pulp Removal: Using specialized instruments, the infected or damaged pulp tissue is carefully removed from the pulp chamber and root canals.
  • Cleaning and Shaping: The dentist cleans and shapes the inside of the root canals to remove any debris, bacteria, and infected tissue.
  • Filling: Once the canals are cleaned, they are filled with a biocompatible material, usually gutta-percha, to seal them and prevent recontamination.
  • Sealing: The access opening in the tooth is sealed with a temporary or permanent filling to prevent bacteria from entering the tooth.
  • Restoration: In some cases, a dental crown may be placed over the treated tooth to provide additional protection and restore its strength and function.

Overall, root canals are highly effective in saving teeth from extraction and relieving pain associated with infection or damage to the pulp.

How to Know if You Need a Root Canal?

Determining whether you need a root canal requires professional assessment by a dentist, but several signs and symptoms may indicate the need for this procedure:

Persistent Pain: Severe or persistent tooth pain, especially when chewing or applying pressure, could indicate an infected or damaged tooth nerve.

  • Sensitivity: Heightened sensitivity to hot or cold temperatures, even after the stimuli are removed, may indicate nerve damage.
  • Gum Swelling: Swelling or tenderness in the gums near the affected tooth may suggest an infection spreading beyond the tooth’s roots.
  • Tooth Discoloration: Darkening or discoloration of the tooth, particularly if it appears gray or black, could indicate nerve damage or infection.
  • Prolonged Sensitivity: If sensitivity to hot or cold persists long after the stimulus is removed, it may indicate nerve damage or infection.
  • Visible Damage: Cracks, chips, or visible decay on the tooth’s surface may expose the pulp to bacteria, leading to infection or inflammation.
  • Abscess Formation: The development of a pimple-like bump on the gums, accompanied by pus or drainage, may indicate a dental abscess, which often requires root canal treatment.

If you experience any of these symptoms, it’s essential to consult a dentist promptly for an evaluation and appropriate treatment recommendations. Early intervention can prevent further complications and help preserve the affected tooth.

Difference between Root Canal and Apicoectomy

Root canal treatment and apicoectomy are both dental procedures aimed at treating issues related to the tooth’s root and surrounding tissues. While they share some similarities, they also have significant differences in terms of procedure, purpose, and outcomes.

Root Canal Treatment:

  • Procedure: Root canal treatment involves the removal of infected or damaged pulp tissue from inside the tooth’s root canal system.
  • Purpose: It is performed to save a tooth that is severely decayed, infected, or damaged due to trauma.
  • Outcome: The goal is to remove infection, relieve pain, and preserve the natural tooth structure by cleaning, shaping, and sealing the root canal space.


  • Procedure: Apicoectomy is a surgical procedure performed when conventional root canal treatment is not sufficient to address persistent infection or inflammation at the tip of the tooth’s root.
  • Purpose: It aims to remove the infected or inflamed tissue at the root tip and seal the apex to prevent further infection.
  • Outcome: Apicoectomy is often considered when a tooth has persistent symptoms or when retreatment of the root canal is not feasible.


  • Scope of Treatment: Root canal treatment addresses issues within the tooth’s root canal system, while apicoectomy focuses on resolving problems at the tip of the tooth’s root.
  • Invasiveness: Apicoectomy is a more invasive procedure than root canal treatment as it involves surgical access to the root tip through the gums.
  • Success Rate: While both procedures have high success rates, root canal treatment is generally more predictable and less complex than apicoectomy.
AspectRoot Canal TreatmentApicoectomy
Procedure ComplexityModerateComplex
Scope of TreatmentInside Root CanalRoot Tip
InvasivenessLess InvasiveMore Invasive
Success RateHighHigh
Common IndicationsTooth Decay, InfectionPersistent Infection, Failed Root Canal

The choice between root canal treatment and apicoectomy depends on various factors, including the extent of the problem, the tooth’s condition, and the patient’s overall oral health. It is essential to consult with a dental professional to determine the most appropriate treatment option.


Pros and Cons of Root Canal vs Apicoectomy

Root canal treatment and apicoectomy are both valuable procedures for treating dental issues related to the tooth’s root, but they come with their own set of advantages and disadvantages. Understanding these can help patients make informed decisions about their dental care.

Pros of Root Canal Treatment:

  • High Success Rate: Root canal treatment has a success rate of around 95%, making it a reliable option for saving teeth.
  • Preservation of Natural Tooth: It allows patients to keep their natural tooth, maintaining function and appearance.
  • Pain Relief: Root canal treatment alleviates tooth pain caused by infection or inflammation.
  • Cost-Effective: Compared to tooth extraction and replacement options, root canal treatment is often more cost-effective in the long run.

Cons of Root Canal Treatment:

  • Multiple Visits: Some cases may require multiple visits to complete the procedure fully.
  • Potential Complications: While rare, complications such as reinfection or incomplete removal of infected tissue can occur.
  • Post-Treatment Care: Patients may experience temporary discomfort or sensitivity after the procedure, requiring adherence to post-treatment care instructions.

Pros of Apicoectomy:

  • Address Persistent Issues: Apicoectomy is effective in resolving persistent infection or inflammation at the root tip that cannot be adequately treated with conventional root canal treatment.
  • Preserve Tooth Structure: Like root canal treatment, apicoectomy aims to preserve the natural tooth, avoiding the need for extraction.
  • Success in Complex Cases: It can be successful in cases where conventional root canal treatment has failed or is not feasible due to anatomical challenges.

Cons of Apicoectomy:

  • Invasiveness: Apicoectomy is a surgical procedure that involves cutting into the gum tissue to access the root tip, leading to potential discomfort and longer recovery times compared to nonsurgical root canal treatment.
  • Risk of Complications: As with any surgical procedure, there is a risk of complications such as infection, bleeding, or damage to surrounding structures.
  • Higher Cost: Apicoectomy is generally more expensive than root canal treatment due to its surgical nature and the need for specialized equipment and expertise.
Pros of Root Canal TreatmentCons of Root Canal TreatmentPros of ApicoectomyCons of Apicoectomy
High Success RateMultiple VisitsAddress Persistent IssuesInvasiveness
Preservation of Natural ToothPotential ComplicationsPreserve Tooth StructureRisk of Complications
– Pain Relief- Cost-EffectivePost-Treatment CareSuccess in Complex CasesHigher Cost

Average Price of Root Canal Treatment in Orlando FL

Root canal treatment costs can vary depending on several factors, including the severity of the tooth’s condition, the location of the dental practice, and whether the procedure is performed by a general dentist or an endodontist. 

In Orlando, FL, patients can expect to pay an average of $500 to $1,500 for a standard root canal procedure.

Factors Affecting Root Canal Treatment Costs:

  • Tooth Location: Root canals on front teeth typically cost less than those on molars due to differences in complexity and accessibility.
  • Extent of Damage: Teeth with extensive decay or damage may require more extensive root canal therapy, which can increase the overall cost.
  • Dental Provider: Endodontists, who specialize in root canal treatment, may charge higher fees than general dentists due to their advanced training and expertise.
  • Additional Procedures: If additional procedures such as post placement or crown restoration are needed after the root canal, they will incur additional costs.

Insurance Coverage and Financing Options:

  • Dental Insurance: Many dental insurance plans provide coverage for root canal treatment, typically covering a portion of the cost. 

Patients should check with their insurance provider to understand their coverage and any out-of-pocket expenses.

  • Payment Plans: Some dental practices offer financing options or payment plans to help patients manage the cost of treatment. These plans may allow patients to spread out payments over time, making treatment more affordable.

Do I Need Root Canal or Apicoectomy

Determining whether you need a root canal or an apicoectomy depends on various factors, including the condition of the tooth and the extent of the dental issue. Here are some considerations to help you decide:

  • Severity of Infection: If the infection is limited to the tooth’s pulp and root canal treatment can effectively remove the infection, a root canal may be sufficient.
  • Extent of Damage: If the infection persists after a root canal or if the damage is located at the root tip, an apicoectomy may be necessary to remove the infected tissue and seal the root tip.
  • Previous Treatment: If you have undergone a root canal procedure but continue to experience symptoms such as pain or swelling, your dentist may recommend an apicoectomy to address any lingering issues.

Consultation with a Dental Professional:

  • Diagnostic Tests: Your dentist or endodontist may perform diagnostic tests such as X-rays or a pulp vitality test to assess the tooth’s condition and determine the most appropriate treatment.
  • Treatment Recommendations: Based on the evaluation and diagnostic findings, your dental provider will recommend the most suitable treatment option to address your dental issue effectively.
  • Consideration of Alternatives: In some cases, alternative treatments such as retreatment of the root canal or extraction followed by tooth replacement may be considered based on your individual circumstances.

Key Takeaways: Root Canal vs Apicoectomy

Making the decision between a root canal and an apicoectomy involves considering several key factors. Here are the main points to remember:

  • Severity of Infection: Root canal treatment is typically the first line of defense for infected teeth with damage limited to the pulp. However, if the infection persists or extends to the root tip, an apicoectomy may be necessary.
  • Extent of Damage: A root canal focuses on removing infected tissue from the tooth’s interior, while an apicoectomy involves assessing and treating the infected tissue around the tooth’s root tip.
  • Success Rates: Both procedures have high success rates, with root canals being successful in about 85-97% of cases and apicoectomies showing success rates of 85-95%.

Consultation with a Specialist:

  • Expert Evaluation: Consult with an endodontist to assess your specific dental condition and receive personalized treatment recommendations.
  • Comprehensive Care: Choose a dental practice like East Orange Endodontics that offers specialized care and expertise in performing both root canals and apicoectomies.
  • Educational Resources: Take advantage of resources provided by your dental provider to learn more about the procedures, their benefits, and what to expect during treatment

For optimal dental care tailored to your specific needs, trust East Orange Endodontics. With their expertise and commitment to excellence, you can confidently address your dental health concerns and achieve lasting results.


Conclusion: Root Canal vs Apicoectomy

In the debate between a root canal and an apicoectomy, the decision ultimately hinges on various factors such as the severity of the dental issue, the extent of damage to the tooth and surrounding tissues, and the patient’s overall oral health. 

East Orange Endodontics offers specialized care in both procedures, ensuring patients receive tailored treatment plans that prioritize long-term dental health and well-being.

While root canals are a common and effective way to address infections and damage within the tooth, apicoectomies provide a more targeted approach for cases where a root canal alone may not suffice. 

By offering comprehensive evaluations and personalized treatment options, East Orange Endodontics empowers patients to make informed decisions about their dental care, promoting optimal outcomes and satisfaction.

FAQs: Root Canal vs Apicoectomy

Is an apicoectomy more painful than a root canal?

Research suggests that while both procedures involve mild discomfort, an apicoectomy may result in slightly more post-operative pain due to the nature of the surgery. However, advancements in anesthesia and pain management techniques have significantly minimized discomfort levels for both procedures. 

Related Posts

Let's save your tooth

Contact Us

We will get in touch as soon as possible!

Experiencing Tooth Pain? Book your Root Canal in Orlando, FL

Over 100,000 Root Canals Performed

30+ Years of Award-Winning Expertise

Top-Rated Endodontist

Choose proven experience !